The solar energy landscape is evolving rapidly, with advancements in photovoltaic (PV) technologies offering new opportunities for clean, sustainable power generation. Two primary contenders in the solar energy market are thin-film solar cells and traditional silicon-based solar cells. While efficiency is a critical factor in determining the viability of a PV technology, it is essential to consider other factors such as cost, material availability, and environmental impact. In this article, we compare the efficiency of thin-film solar cells to their silicon-based counterparts and discuss additional factors that influence their adoption in the market.
Silicon-based solar cells, specifically crystalline silicon (c-Si) cells, have dominated the solar energy market for decades. These cells have achieved power conversion efficiencies of around 20% for commercial products and up to 26.7% for laboratory-scale cells. However, silicon-based solar cells have limitations, including high production costs and a significant carbon footprint during manufacturing.
Thin-film solar cells, on the other hand, are an emerging technology that offers potential advantages over traditional silicon-based cells. Current thin-film technologies, such as cadmium telluride (CdTe) and copper indium gallium selenide (CIGS), have reached efficiencies of around 22.1% and 23.4%, respectively, in laboratory settings. Although these numbers are comparable to c-Si cells, commercially available thin-film cells typically achieve efficiencies between 10% and 13%.
Next-Generation Thin-Film Solar Cells
The 5GSOLAR project, led by the Laboratory of Thin Films Chemical Technologies at TalTech, aims to develop next-generation thin-film solar cells using earth-abundant chalcogenide materials such as antimony and bismuth-based chalcogenides. These materials have unique properties, such as tunable bandgaps and high absorption coefficients, which enable power conversion efficiencies of around 10% in superstrate and substrate configurations. While the efficiencies of these next-generation thin-film cells are still lower than their silicon-based counterparts, they offer several advantages in terms of material availability, cost, and environmental impact.
Additional Factors to Consider
Material availability: Thin-film solar cells are made using abundant and non-toxic materials, unlike some silicon-based cells that require scarce elements like silver and indium. This abundance of materials reduces the overall cost and environmental impact of thin-film cells.
Cost: Thin-film solar cells have lower production costs compared to silicon-based cells, as they require less material and have simpler manufacturing processes. This cost advantage makes thin-film cells more attractive for large-scale applications and utility-scale solar projects.
Environmental impact: Thin-film solar cells have a lower carbon footprint and reduced environmental impact compared to silicon-based cells, as they use non-toxic materials and have a lower energy demand during production.
Flexibility and adaptability: Thin-film solar cells can be easily integrated into various applications, such as building-integrated photovoltaics (BIPV), agro photovoltaics, and product-integrated photovoltaics (PIPV), providing versatile solutions for a range of energy needs.
While the efficiencies of thin-film solar cells are currently lower than traditional silicon-based solar cells, they offer several advantages in terms of material availability, cost, and environmental impact. As research and development in the field of thin-film PV technologies continue, we can expect the efficiency gap between these two types of solar cells to narrow. In the future, the combination of efficiency improvements and the inherent advantages of thin-film solar cells could make them a competitive alternative to silicon-based solar cells in various applications.
Learn more about going solar by clicking the following links: